Does TV Capture The True Scope Of Diversity?

Growing up, The Disney Channel was my bread and butter.

As I was sucked into the world of Lizzie McGuire, Even Stevens, and more, I wasn’t really aware that a majority of the characters I watched on my beloved television channel were mostly reflections of myself. Namely, white.

tumblr_m5bjdvSOOG1qzzkr9o1_500
Source: Tumblr

Luckily, there were blips on the radar. The Proud Family, That’s So Raven, and re-runs of Sister, Sister all added a little bit of racial variety to my viewing habits.




I transitioned into ‘older’ television shows rapidly. Dark Angel and Alias were my two all-time favorites, because at the ripe age of 11, I skipped right over The WB for the edgier stuff. (And later returned to The CW because of Chuck Bass.) Diversity was there, but I only saw it in minor characters. A lesbian black best friend that killed two birds with one stone. The occasional Asian guest star.

However, it wasn’t until my parents adopted my little sister, who is black, that I began to notice a problem on television: there weren’t enough characters representing her. She got older and watched live-action programs on The Disney Channel and Nickelodeon, and suddenly I began noticing that her personality changed to reflect that which she saw on television.

There were black characters on her favorite shows, fortunately, but they were predominately the sidekicks. Sassy little black girls who talked too loud, got in trouble a lot, and generally did a lot of finger snapping. So what happened? She talked too loud, got in a lot of trouble, and perfected the z snap.

It was then that I noticed the problem with diversity on television isn’t just the number of characters representing a different segment of the population – whether that’s race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, etc – but the manner in which those segments are represented.




I mean, it’s good if we have black women on television for my sister to see as role models – and little girls tend to pick up things from what they watch on TV, but what about black women who break the stereotypes? What about the black main character who is the girl-next-door? The smart one? The quiet one? The kickass vigilante? The heartbreaker?

I didn’t see it, and I felt guilty that I had the ability to truly envision myself as  female characters ranging from Lizzie McGuire to Sydney Bristow, picking and choosing who I wanted to be, while she was relegated to a small subset of the population.

Thankfully, diversity in television is hitting an all-time high these days. We’ve got shows like Black-ish, The Mindy Project, Fresh Off The Boat, Jane The Virgin, Scandal, and more all reclaiming our television screens with more life and diversity than ever before.

“Now what you have are lead characters and whole families that are complex, flawed and kind of terrible sometimes and different from each other and funny and stupid,” Michael Schur, executive producer of Master of None, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, and Parks and Recreation, told Variety. “…all of the things that white people have been able to be on TV forever.”

Not only that, we’re watching groundbreakers like Viola Davis becoming the first black star to win an Emmy for the outstanding lead actress in a drama series for How To Get Away With Murder.

Is it enough? Earlier this year USC Annenberg released the Comprehensive Annenberg Report on Diversity (CARD), which found that “only 28.3% of all speaking characters across 414 films, television and digital episodes in 2014-15 were from underrepresented racial/ethnic groups.” More than that, only one-third of all speaking characters were female.

We might have a long way to go, but I’m glad to see how far we’ve come and I can’t wait to see what happens next.




Jandra

Writer. Tweeter. Doer of many things. Pluto broke my heart. May or may not be a descendant of Odin.

Currently residing in Nashville, TN.

  • Caryn Welby-Solomon

    Thank you so much for this article. I’m oddly mixed-race African and I grabbed onto any slightly tanned character just to feel represented in some shape or form and many times I wonder if my need to constantly be in the background comes from always relating to the side characters, the ‘invisible’ ones. I wonder how different my life would have been if I had seen myself in Buffy or Marissa Cooper or even Xena. Now that I am older I know that characters don’t have to look like me for me to identify with them, but that is how we begin to relate. So yes, I agree with you that TV has improved so much since most of us were young, and hope it continues to still improve that all children will have a range of rolemodels to look up to that are complex, interesting and have depth.

  • Pingback: “I am not ashamed to be coloured” - Pink Shackles()

Paying Bills
Blogs We Love