Fangirlish Gift Guides: For The ‘Supernatural’ Fan In Your Life

It’s the final season of Supernatural and to be honest, we’re going to miss it so much. It’s a weekly must see show and has been an instrumental part of our life in fandom.

With the show ending, there are a lot of fans who want Supernatural themed gifts for Christmas. So if you don’t watch the show, are at a loss on what to get – don’t worry. We have you covered.

Conquest Journals

Cost: Varies

You can join the hunt and keep your notes in this John Winchester Replica Journal. It comes with –

  • 6″ x 9″ PU (faux) Leather 3 ring binder with 3 inner pockets, HW embossed and pen loop
  • Replica pages with original artwork
  • 40 blank lined pages
  • 5 Newspaper articles including funeral notice, Provenance episode article and House Fire piece
  • Mystery Spot brochure
  • Biggerson’s Turducken ad

And it is beautiful.


Stands Season 15 Varsity Jacket

Cost: $44.99

Stands does a lot of Supernatural themed merch and helps the fandom raise money for charity.

Celebrate the senior year of wwith this limited edition, exclusive Season 15 Varsity Jacket! A portion of proceeds will go to Animal Allies.

The back of the jacket simply says, “There’ll be peace, when you are done.”

The jacket also comes in crimson.



Supernatural: The Official Cookbook

COST: $24.15

This cookbook had me with the cover. Why? Cause PIE.

Filled with delicious recipes inspired by the hit television series, this cookbook allows fans to experience the world of Supernatural like never before.

Whether you’re a seasoned chef, beginner cook, or diner food enthusiast like the Winchester Brothers, Supernatural: The Official Cookbook brings a variety both savory and sweet recipes from the show to life. When they aren’t keeping humanity safe from all kinds of otherworldly threats, Dean and Sam often take time to eat and devise their next steps for hunting monsters at a small-town diner. This complete culinary guide features some of the brothers’ favorite dishes, such as Dean’s breakfast Pigs ‘N A Poke, cheeseburger and fries, angel food cake, Sam’s salads—and, of course, pie!

Featuring other recipes inspired by characters and locations and complete with illustrations, recipe modifications, and mouthwatering full-color photos, this cookbook will inspire you to not wait for your next road trip and prepare your own delicious feast.


USAOPOLY Supernatural Collector’s Edition Clue Board Game

Cost: $89.99

I mean here is the thing – I never thought I would tell anyone to spend a lot of money on a board game, but with this one, why not. It’s a collectors edition of Clue.

It comes with 6 Collectible mover pieces, 6 custom weapons and has a custom designed game board. 

The only thing that would suck about it is that I wouldn’t want to open it, because like I said, collectors item.



COST: $9.38

Sure, if we could we’d buy an Impala that you could drive for our friends, but I don’t know about you – I am not rich.

Greenlight Collectibles 1:64 Scale Hollywood Series 6 Die Cast Vehicle by GL Hollywood will do.

The vehicle is about three inches long and is limited edition.

Dean and Sam Winchester not included.


Supernatural TV Show Cast Autographed Signed Reprint 8.5×11 Script Framed 13×15 

COST: $25.00

Let me reiterate that this is a reprint and not an original signed script cover.

The page has the reprinted signatures of Jensen Ackles, Jared Padalecki, Misha Collins, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, and Mark Sheppard. 

It is unframed.

The complete script comes without the frame packed securely with waterproof packaging and ship in cardboard envelope.

And it’s affordable.


Double – Sided Supernatural Coffee Mug, 11 oz. Ceramic Supernatural Gift Mug – Anti-Possession Symbol, Devil’s Trap,Stay Inside the Salt Ring, and Saving People Hunting Things

COST: $23.99

Who doesn’t want something fun to drink out of? I do.

This double sided mug is cute.

Ceramic 11oz. double sided coffee/tea mug and magnet gift set Set of TWO: Includes one mug AND one ceramic magnet with Dean’s iconic car, Baby!

It comes gift ready in a gift box, which makes it easy to give as a gift.


Supernatural Inspired – You’re The Sam to My Dean & The Dean to My Sam – A Hand Stamped Bracelet Set Aluminum

COST: $21.00

You’re the Sam to my Dean.

You’re the Dean to my Sam.

Made by the professional artisans at Hand Trades with over 15 years experience in crafting jewelry and accessories.


Supernatural Dean Winchester Scented Candle Castiel Supernatural Gift Winchester Brothers

COST: $26.00

You know that we’re obsessed with candles. I can’t imagine one smelling better than apple pie.

This is a Dean Winchester Apple Pie Scented Hand Poured Soy Candle.

Completely Handmade in Astoria, Oregon!

Comes ready to gift in a lovely gift box. Perfect Holiday Gift or Anytime Gift for the Supernatural Fan!

Approximate Burn Time 50 Hours. 9 oz Candle.


The Adventurous Eaters Club: Mastering the Art of Family Mealtime

COST: $18.24

TV star Misha Collins and his wife, journalist and historian Vicki Collins, show families how to be mealtime adventurers so that kids might have a lifelong relationship with real food

Chicken nuggets. Hot dogs. Macaroni and cheese. These are just some of the greatest hits we offer kids at mealtime.

Misha and Vicki Collins totally get it. When their son West was a toddler, he began refusing anything that wasn’t bland and beige. At first, they succumbed, anything to end the mealtime battles. But with sinking hearts they realized fruit snacks and buttered noodles weren’t just void of nutrition, they were setting him up for a lifetime with a limited palate and a reliance on convenience foods.

So, as a family, they decided to lean into what they love best—adventure—and invited their kids to be playful and exploratory in the kitchen. Now, in The Adventurous Eaters Club, Misha and Vicki share how they created a home where mealtime doesn’t involve coercion or trickery, and where salad, veggies, fresh soups, and fruit are the main course. Combining personal anecdotes and practical tips with over 100 creative, delicious, whimsical recipes little hands can help prepare The Adventurous Eaters Club offers readers all the support, encouragement, and practical advice they need to make lifelong adventurous eaters out of their kids.


Basically Everything Supernatural At Hot Topic

COST: Varies

Hot Topic has a lot of Supernatural Merch. They have everything – from shirts to blankets to shoes. Everything you could ever want is there.


Supernatural poster alternative poster Chevrolet Impala poster Crime show poster Thriller 60s

COST: $8.00 and up

Poster printed on high quality premium paper, ready for framing. Interior design is just for mock up purposes.

It does not come framed.

We love the vintage feel and the feels that it gives us.


What would you get the Supernatural fan in your life? 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.