The Institute Season 2 is two episodes in, and it has action-packed and jaw-dropping moments. But one moment in particular that was jaw-dropping for me came in The Institute Season 2 Episode 2, The Sanctuary.’ Be forewarned: if you haven’t seen the episode, I am about to reveal a spoiler. As we all know, the kids escaped The Institute in Season 1. Season 2 is all about them trying to figure out how to end the Institute once and for all.
Luke, who recently learned he is a precog or “PC,” went on a rogue mission to retrieve the only proof they had of the Institute’s existence. That proof is a flash drive with video footage. And Sigsby has it. After Luke’s mission to retrieve it failed epically, he had no choice but to make a deal with her. Part of the deal was that not only he but also Kalisha and Nicky would be taken back to the Institute.
MORE: Read our review of The Institute Season 2, Episode 1, ‘The Reckoning.’

All I could think watching that episode was, “What was Luke thinking? And why did Tim let him do this?” Well, Fangirlish had to get the answer when we sat down with Ben Barnes and Joe Freeman, stars of The Institute, for our exclusive interview.
Freeman kicked things off. “I think that’s one of the worst things we’ve seen him do. Probably the worst thing Luke’s done in the show is give his mates up like that. When I read that, I didn’t know why he was doing that. I think as much as we’d like to say it’s to save his mates, it’s also an ego thing. I think. He wants to be the one to take this place down. He hates what they do. So it’s an ego thing. He doesn’t want to lose to these people.”
This was an excellent response and a great way to look at the reasoning behind Luke’s decision. I can honestly agree this is by far the worst thing Luke has done. Kalisha and Nicky are his friends. For him to set it up for them to be taken back to the Institute, a place where they suffered so much, is just wrong. Tim himself saw footage of what happened there, so letting Luke go through with his plan was shocking. We had to know what Barnes thought about Tim’s decision.

“I think Tim doesn’t want him to do this. He’s so deeply concerned with protecting this boy that he cares about so much, but he’s also fueled by a deep propulsion to do good and to do the right thing. He doesn’t have a better idea. I think that’s the truth of it: sometimes the best course of action is the least worst idea, and he doesn’t have a better one.”
That makes a lot of sense because, as I’ve been watching this season, I’ve been wondering how they could take the Institute down. Since The Institute Season 2, Episode 1, things have been a mess. Luke exposed them all when he rescued a mom and her child, so they lost the element of surprise. Tim is a fish out of water. All of this was basically thrust upon him. He wasn’t inside the Institute when Luke, Kalisha, and Nicky worked together to come up with an escape plan. So, I can see why he’s just let Luke take the reins.
Before closing out the interview, we had to ask Joe whether he believes Luke feels what he did to Kalisha and Nicky was a betrayal, especially now that he knows he’s a PC. To find out his answer, check out the full interview below:
The Institute releases new episodes every Sunday on MGM+.