Dancing with the Stars is finally back with Season 35. With 16 celebrities and pros, this season is tied with the show’s largest cast yet. It also welcomes two new pros and a returning pro back to the ballroom. There’s a lot to look forward to this season. There is the podcast with Andy Richter, the after show with Robert Irwin, and so much more. We’ll be breaking down every episode — what we loved and what we (maybe) didn’t — all season long.
Next up: Dancing with the Stars Season 35, Episode 11, “Semi-Finals!”
MORE: Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Roundtable: Grammy Night

Overall Thoughts?
Shelby: I can’t help but to come into the semi-finals with extremely high expectations. This season has been so intense and competitive. Thankfully, the vibes in the ballroom are excellent, which hasn’t always been the truth this season. Everyone just seems like they’re finally letting themselves allocate being a part of this show and this experience again — just as it’s starting to come to an end. The sky box was a whole party.
Shana: I can’t believe we started the semifinals off with a slow, careful, weight-misplaced jive that then got…8s. The good news is the night improved from there (until, uh, the very end), and there was very much a party energy going on whenever anyone went over to get their scores.
You’ve got folks singing the song Harry and Jenna did their paso to, Maura collapsing and screaming about loving the samba, Amber Glenn getting Level 4s and +5 GOE (figure skating reference), Tatyana channeling my inner perfectionist and being like “no” after Jan told her she did a “nice” job in their rehearsal package…all good stuff!
MORE: Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Roundtable: Disney Night

Best Moment(s) from Favorite Partnership(s)?
Shelby: One thing I always appreciate about the Daniella Karagach is that she never waters down her choreography for any of her partners. She filled that Quickstep with content and an edge, and it paid off in an incredible dance. And, honestly, I really love how competitive Daniella is feeling, too. That energy extended right into their Jive to “Footloose.” They’re such a high-energy pairing that continues to make my jaw drop. I mean, Ezra really puts his all into every performance. I am so, SO happy for them and their perfect score.
Shana: That little moment at the end of Harry Shum Jr.’s paso doble was unexpectedly sweet, especially coming after such a strong performance with so much fire—also literally!—before it. Little kiss to the palm, little pat to the cheek, big ol’ smile. Awwwwwww.
MORE: Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Roundtable: Horror Movie Night

BOTTOM: JULIANNE HOUGH, MAURA HIGGINS, MARK BALLAS

Favorite Dance(s) and Why?
Shelby: I heard Maura say that she finds everything about the Samba difficult, and then I saw her go out there and have an absolute blast. And starting out there by herself? The confidence! The trust that Mark Ballas has in his partner. That was flawless to my eye. She never got stuck in her head, and she did a gorgeous job technically. I’m just OBSESSED. And their reactions to that first 10 and their perfect score?! DESERVED.
There’s a moment or two in Maura and Mark’s Viennese Waltz when they made eye contact, and I could see the smiles in their eyes. They were just gliding out there and having the best time. You could see them settle into this elegant number. I’m so glad that the judges were giving Mark his flowers because he is one of the best pros this show has ever seen. But he’s also a brilliant teacher. Maura has never danced before, and she’s in the semi-finals performing numbers like this.
Amber and Pasha doing a Viennese Waltz to “Dangerous Woman?” Oh, I was locked in from the jump. Even the rocky camera work couldn’t pull me out of this dance. She interprets movement so well. I don’t agree with Derek often, but I do think that Amber is the most consistent in this competition.
If I could vote for Tatyana and Jan a million times, I would and it still wouldn’t be enough. The confidence she had in that ChaCha just made me appreciate the journey she’s been on this season. I keep saying it, but it’s true. Tatyana really is the most improved this season. She’s really settled into herself and her capabilities as a dancer this season. And, for what it’s worth, Jan has also grown so much as a pro this season. He’s so important to this show’s future. I just know it. And guess what? THEY GOT A 10!!!
Shana: Ezra and Daniella’s quickstep was a killer. Pretty sure the only other time “Kryptonite” has made me weepy was when I would get so close to hitting all the drum runs on my friend’s Xbox and then would make a stupid mistake back in the day. There were lots of cute, little choreographic moments that highlighted their partnership so well, and although not perfect, it was still really impressive overall.
Ok but like. Amber Glenn’s salsa??? ARE YOU KIDDING ME???!! FINALLY, A PERFECT SCORE. OUR LONG NATIONAL NIGHTMARE IS OVER!!!! She is just so…”let me casually start in a split, do lifts that would make the best ice dancers in the world proud, and throw in a pairs twist while I’m at it” kind of energy. And yet. All of that was also SALSA CONTENT, performed so incredibly well…and um, kinda hot. Is it creepy if I say that? If so, forget I did.
Wow, Maura and Mark! That Viennese waltz was so beautiful. (I’m once again asking for just one hour with this man’s instructional skills.)
Hm. As a surprise to no one, I’m also obsessed with Amber’s Viennese waltz. “Impeccable” spins indeed! And to see her go from so fierce throughout the performance—especially that ending pose—to all that joy immediately after totally shows what a true performer she is. Equally strong and lovely, which is basically the Amber Glenn way.
And last, but most definitely not least: The growth Tatyana has had on this series was so stunningly, beautifully evident in her cha cha. Yes, the technique note Derek and Bruno made was correct. But when you look at the overall journey and the way her confidence has just blossomed, it’s insane.
MORE: Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Roundtable: Dedication Night

Most Unexpected or Underrated Moment(s)?
Shelby: Harry Shum Jr. dancing to two songs that have been covered in Glee is something so personal to me. Doing a Quickstep to “Valerie” is an homage to Glee makes me ridiculously emotional. “And to be able to dance to Naya’s version.” “We miss you, baby girl.” I sobbed. I’m just a proud Harry Shum Jr. fan and a super proud Gleek.
I have been waiting for these judges to properly give Amber Glenn (and Pasha) her flowers. It felt like they finally saw her for the competitor and performer that she is. They saw the work she put into this dance. I was nervous before the scores that this would be another week where her scores didn’t match her effort. And, thankfully, they finally got that perfect score. I am literally over the moon for them.
Crying my eyes out at the dancers and troupe bowing down to Tatyana in the sky box. Exactly! And then I cried again when Tatyana and Jan got emotional in the package for their second dance. It’s really moving to see them show up for each other and get stronger every single week.
They got Hozier on DWTS?! And the cheers when the audience realized that they’re using his song? I cheered from my seat.
Shana: Uh. So. There’s favoritism, and then, there’s whatever that was with Carrie Ann going and, like, coaching Connor, or whatever. No, it’s not just about nerves. He’s been this bad all along, and y’all have been glazing him. Utterly shocked at the flagrant favoritism she and Derek continue to show towards this guy, especially when they’ve rightly called out mistakes from others who have otherwise performed way better—and consistently at that. Like, what did I watch??? The only person who was halfway for real was Bruno, and he…still gave the same score as this guy’s biggest fans. Ok. Sure. Why not. (Where’s Shirley Ballas when you need her?)
The numerical gap between Connor and Harry’s (deserved) perfection was nowhere near enough. While we’re at it, that was the most sluggish cover of “Dance, Dance” I’ve ever heard in my entire life. It was listening to every single member of Fall Out Boy slowly bleed out in real time. If you need a song like that to drag that much to halfway hope your dance partner can master the style, and it’s not typically a style known for sluggishness, that says a lot.
“We miss you, baby girl.” Sobbing. (And my cat’s giving me the “WTF is wrong with you” look for it.)
I could say a lot of things about representation and disability, but those videos of kids seeing Ezra competing and seeing themselves says way more than I ever could. Also appreciate Ezra deliberately saying “the disabled community” after Julianne said the awkward “differently abled” phrase. There’s a huge difference between being an inspiration and toxic inspo p**n. Ezra is 100% the former while these people are trying to make him the latter…and, thankfully, failing.
My heart. Watching everyone celebrate with Tatyana after her cha cha made me so emotional, I can’t. Help. Just…HELP.
MORE: Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Roundtable: Super Bowl Night

Reaction to Elimination
Shelby: Oh, my stomach was in knots. Until I had the total relief of Tatyana and Jan making it to that finale. And Alfonso being the one to say it means everything. I actually don’t know how Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna aren’t going to the finale. He is such a brilliant dancer, and he should be in that finale. He’s a good dancer and people want to watch good dancers. Or at least…that’s what I thought. I truly feel like Carrie Ann when the camera cuts to her. Wild!
Shana: Connor didn’t belong here, and he definitely doesn’t belong in the finale. I’m not even trying to be mean—it is what it is! Still, I really don’t know how you can watch tonight’s performances and think he doesn’t stick out like a sore thumb. But sure, Derek “predicted” it weeks ago. The judges’ bending over backwards to justify somewhat competitive numbers and reassure him that he’s sooooooo good weren’t at all on purpose! K.
Oh, but the relief when Carlton got to be like “MY BABY SISTER TATYANA!!!!”
Basically, it’s a “tag yourself: I’m Carrie Ann’s frozen, awkward, barely able to clap, shock” kind of moment with Harry. He did so well tonight, and it would’ve been so much fun to get to see him do a freestyle. I’m kinda pis**d, if I’m being honest. The only thing keeping me tuning in next week is my girls.
MORE: Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Roundtable: Mariah Carey Night
—