NCIS: New York Season 1, Episode 6 ‘My Companion‘ is proof that when a show is this new, an episode has the power to change things. Sure, things might not be jelling quite yet, but it’s too early to decide that means something. Because one episode after an hour that turned me off Nick Schaeffer (Scott Caan), the show actually managed to give him some personality quirks that kinda work, while making the bigger question why Sam (LL Cool J) is even in New York in the first place.
Again, it’s very early. This might all turn out well. Considering the franchise, it probably will. NCIS: New York has shown us enough so far to believe that, if given the time, I could learn to love all these characters separately. What it hasn’t really done yet, though this episode is a step forward, is convince me that I’m going to love these characters together. And an NCIS show lives and dies by the found family dynamics.
Outside of that, the hour is a pretty good showcase of the dangers of AI and the world we live in, one that for anyone who is chronically online might feel unnecessary, but that might really work for this show’s core audience. Empathy and compassion cannot be found in machines, and more often than not, they are what we need to get through the day.
MORE: Is Scott Caan playing the same character here as he did in NCIS: Los Angeles? We’ve got the answer.
SAM ALREADY HAD A FAMILY

The problem with Sam Hanna right now is that it feels like he’s starting from scratch in the “found family” department, and I’m not sure why he would. I mean, sure, he’s coming back home and all, but I already wasn’t sure why he would leave Los Angeles to go to Hawai’i and I’m less sure of why he would now come to New York. The multiple shows he’s been in have never explained that! In fact, they haven’t even tried to.
But that becomes a problem when he’s trying to anchor a team. Did Callen (Chris O’Donnell) really get married, retire, and forget him? Did Kensi (Daniela Ruah) and Deeks (Eric Christian Olsen) have a kid and stop working? Does no one remember that Hetty (Linda Hunt) was kidnapped? And that’s just the issues with leaving his LA team of over a decade. What happened to Jane Tennant (Vanessa Lachey) and her team? Hell, Sam has bonded more with people on NCIS than I’ve seen him bond with anyone here, Nick included.
Again, it’s been only six episodes, but on an hour that actually helps Nick, I’m left needing NCIS: New York to really sell me on why Sam would decide he wanted to start over again at this point in his life. Because it makes no sense to me.
MORE: Here’s how to watch every NCIS show in order
NICK FEELS A LITTLE MORE REAL

This was a good episode for Nick Schaeffer, though. To be clear, he was still somewhat of an annoying brat, but at least we saw more of a personality that felt real and not like he was trying to embody a living stereotype. Turns out you can be somewhat unbearable and still win me over, because at least there was a spark of a real personality there. Plus, that final moment with Sean might have been the best Nick has been so far.
Ironically, as much as the show has struggled at times with both Sam and Nick, I feel all the other characters work very well. I want more of Sean (Devin Druid), especially after what we saw him do at the end of this hour. I want more of Wells, particularly after that clinical interrogation. And where was she at in that dress? Plus, both Addy (Jacqueline Byers) and Wyatt (Shane Harper) have shown us enough that I firmly believe that, with some love and time, we might have a Densi situation in our hands.
The rest still needs work, but again, it’s very early. I’m calling it as I see it so far, but things can change very quickly. That’s the beauty and the pain of investing in a new show.
MORE: How did NCIS: Los Angeles end?
Things I think I think:
- Sure, sure, finishing dinner with friends.
- You really went and got dressed up for this, Sam?
- “You don’t think about us?”
- “The 25-year-old girl that you left.” Ouch, Sam.
- I mean, yeah, apologize to Tamara.
- “I didn’t handle it right” seems like an understatement, even if we don’t know what happened.
- Addy, you cannot be an AI person!
- The milk jokes are getting old. Find new material.
- “How do you know that?”/”Cause I read books”
- And he’s also afraid of existential threats of AI to humanity.
- My man.
- I mean, Nick, you did shoot someone. Standard stuff.
- Take the dog for a walk!
- A dude saves your life, and you’re not even trying to help. Billionaires suck.
- Let me just point out how much time Sam has spent taking orders from women and being totally cool with it.
- “What would you do if it was your son?”
- At least Sam is honest that he doesn’t know.
- “Sometimes the wins feel like losses.”
- Nick having feelings about this is the most human he’s felt.
- “Crazy what shows up on the dark web.”
- Point Nick. And Sean. All kinds of illegal, but whatever.
Are you excited for NCIS: New York Season 1, Episode 6 ‘My Companion’? Share with us in the comments below!
NCIS: New York airs Tuesdays at 9/8c on CBS.