9-1-1 Season 10 Episode 6 “Et Tu” is one of the most frustrating episodes in ages. It’s also one of the episodes where I deeply understand why these characters are acting the way they are, especially Buck. Because sometimes we wish we could break those old habits at the drop of a dime. But trauma doesn’t work like that. Trauma echoes throughout every part of our lives. And right now it’s trauma that is making Buck slip back into harmful coping mechanisms.
Buck isn’t the only one who has had to deal with his past affecting his present. Hen got a blast from the past that led her to have an emotional moment of growth. And Athena was confronted by her past, ended up in an FBI meeting room, and then apparently had a heart attack. That last part we don’t like as much because of how much time until the next episode on ABC. So we’re crossing our fingers that she’s ok.
MORE: Need a reminder of where we last left off? Read our review for 9-1-1 Season 10 Episode 5 “Who’s Your Daddy?”
“That Fight is Over. Release the Fear.”

“That fight is over. Release the fear.” That’s not a quote from 9-1-1. That’s a quote from The Legend of Korra, one of my favorite shows. And in it, Toph is helping Korra get metal that’s poisoning her out of her body. But every single time she tries, she has flashbacks of the hurt that led her to this moment. And I can’t help but think of this quote when I think of Buck and his trauma. Because the fight is over. But he’s still holding onto that fear, letting it destroy his life.
In “Et Tu,” we did see Buck fall back into some bad coping mechanisms because he’s still living in that fear. And I hate that he had to go and mess up to figure it out. But sometimes that’s just how it is. Sometimes you try to guide someone, and there’s only so much you can do before they make that first step for themselves. And that’s what Buck did by the end of this episode. He understood that he was slipping into bad habits again and actually said, out loud, how much he loves Theo.
This is progress for Buck.
In the midst of all of this, I will admit that I was kind of terrified about what direction this Buck storyline was going to go in. Because 9-1-1 does have a habit of not committing to things. But Buck seems to have chosen a direction and is actively going to try to work on this fear so he can get back to Theo. Now I just need this show to lock in. No more backsliding. I need progress. Because we’re in season 10, people. Plus there’s a child on the line waiting for Buck.
MORE: We’ve been saying it’s time for Buddie for a while.
The Buddie of It All

RYAN GUZMAN, KENNETH CHOI, ELIJAH M. COOPER, ANIRUDH PISHARODY, AISHA HINDS, OLIVER STARK
The most surprising part of “Et Tu” wasn’t the truly glorious Eddie and Maddie scene that we got and that we’ve been waiting years for. It also wasn’t that endearing look that Eddie gave Theo when he was playing with Jee. The most surprising part of this episode was that Buck actually went to Eddie’s house to apologize. Even better, he told Eddie, who has continuously doubted his ability as a father, that he’s a good dad.
This is progress. This is hope. But this also tells me as a viewer that Buck and Eddie are going to be okay. Because I think Buck finally realizes that Eddie wasn’t trying to betray him when he took Theo in. He was trying to protect Buck by protecting his heart, aka Theo. And I just don’t know where 9-1-1 can go with this storyline besides Buck and Eddie being a happy little family by the end of this because the fact that Eddie knew that Theo was his heart matters on a fundamental level to their relationship on this show.
Then there’s the moment where Eddie invited Buck to see Theo AND Christopher, and Buck said he wasn’t ready. It took bravery to admit that. It also shows how much love, compassion, and understanding there is between these two that Buck felt comfortable saying that to Eddie. And for Eddie himself, it’s the same thing. He trusts Buck. If he says he needs time, he’s going to take his word for it and make sure that he knows that his door is waiting for Buck.
MORE: Is Eddie Gay? We’ve discussed it before!
Hen and Her Past

Hen’s past and her fears that come with it manifested in a different way in “Et Tu.” And even though I don’t want to see her in pain, I like that they’re remembering something that really changed Hen’s life. Because someone died. And she still thinks about that, ending every day praying for that young woman. This matters.
Admittedly, I would have liked for us to revisit Hen’s past in a slightly different way, and not because a guy died and confessed to running over a kid and not telling anyone. But yeah, what happened to Hen was a painful thing. So I guess they wanted to go that route. Also, Hen and Eddie going to that house to inform the parents about something they heard is… weird. But TV, I guess.
Back to Hen. Like I need 9-1-1 to lock in on Buck’s character development; I also need the show to lock in on giving us more Hen. Because at one point she was going to be a doctor. And now that the show isn’t giving her that storyline or traumatizing her with the possibility of losing her children, they seem to have nothing for an essential character in an ensemble crew.
MORE: 9-1-1 Giving us Buddie Divorce Era (Again) is a Good Thing
Additional Thoughts About “Et Tu”:
- Ravi stepped right into the middle of that. RUN RAVI!
- Athena ain’t do nothing. And even if she did, no she didn’t.
- Theo playdate with Jee is so cute!
- OMG A MADDIE AND EDDIE SCENE
- Eddie standing in the same place Maddie asked Buck if he was in love with Eddie.
- No, I don’t want the Buck sleeping around storyline
- Like I know it’s a coping mechanism. But come on!
- Old patterns. You’re falling right into them. Yes, listen.
- FINALLY MADDIE AND BUCK
- BECOME A BETTER DAD
- Ohhhh Hen connecting to that man. And yes, Hen would’ve stopped.
- Buck… you need to get away from this. Thanks for rescuing her but get away!
- And yeah, almost killed Hayley. Jesus.
- “Nothing can change until you do.”
- That montage had me cryinggggg!
- Ok, now Hen got me crying.
- I know she’s in pain, but I’m glad they remembered this.
- “Put the past behind you and be free of it.”
- BUCK CAME TO EDDIE to APOLOGIZE.
- CRAZY BUSINESS.
- WHAT DO YOU MEAN ATHENA MIGHT HAVE HAD A HEART ATTACK!?
9-1-1 airs new episodes every Thursday at 8/7c on ABC.