Grey’s Anatomy Season 23, Episode 6, “Till I Collapse,” brings everything to a fever pitch as patience and resources run thin. The fall finale, written by Sandra Hamada and directed by Allison Liddi-Brown, lives up to its title across the ensemble of characters. They’re more than overwhelmed as Parsons closes its door, meaning the show jumps a month in time. It’s not counterproductive or distracting for most of the storylines. For some, though, it undercuts them.
“Till I Collapse” starting with Wes returning to work after being away for a month, having the measles, and deciding to break up with Simone out of nowhere is a lot of whiplash. Grey’s Anatomy seems to suggest that Wes is pushing Simone away because of everything he’s dealing with in his personal life. The issue is that the show has yet to properly explore that. It has the chance with Wes having to step away from the hospital. Instead, it skips right past that to unravel the good place that the couple was in just an episode prior.
There’s certainly emotional resonance in Wes losing Keith, another patient who slips through the cracks. But Grey’s Anatomy doesn’t really earn Wes collapsing as the fade-to-black cliffhanger of the fall finale because it misses that critical time with him. That’s not to say that Trevor Jackson doesn’t deliver a fantastic performance throughout “Till I Collapse.” From start to finish, he does — it’s what informs a lot of what’s going on in Wes’s head.
MORE: Grey’s Anatomy Season 23, Episode 5 Review: Facing Your Demons and Doing It Anyway

On the other hand, Grey’s Anatomy has a more consistently represented storyline that could have had the gut punch for that spot. (Even the reveal that Blue is a bone marrow match for his dad is a good twist for the coda!) All season, the show has been progressing Link’s storyline, mostly in the background but still effectively. Amelia noticing the signs and doing the hard but necessary thing to tell Link to step aside is such a seismic moment. I almost didn’t expect for Grey’s Anatomy to follow it up with another scene until January.
Instead, it doubles down. There’s a live-wire current to that scene that just explodes with the reveal that Amelia called Jo to hold Link to account. That scene is some of the best work I’ve seen Caterina Scorsone and Chris Carmack do together on this show. It makes me really look forward to what awaits them in the second half of the season. They have great chemistry! It’s part of the reason why I loved Amelia and Link together in the beginning.
To that point, it’s a relief that Amelia is in a good place while she navigates this with Link. She also has Toni, a truly supportive partner who notices when something is wrong, doesn’t doubt her, and simply asks how she can help. Amelia has come so far from when her loved ones had to stage an intervention on Private Practice. That distance and time comes into sharper focus with the parallels this storyline takes to Amelia’s past. It also makes Amelia stopping Link from making the speech she’s made so many times all the more effective.
There are years of history here. Triggers. Old wounds. Recovery. Betrayal. Growth. It’s all there, sitting on the surface of Scorsone’s performance when Amelia’s hands shake. And there are all of these new layers.
MORE: Grey’s Anatomy Season 23, Episode 4 Review: Surprises Aren’t for Everyone

Link isn’t just someone she cares about. He was someone who was about to operate while under the influence. (Though, Link clearly wanted to avoid surgery, not because it was right for Joanne, but because it was easier for him. There are so many nuances to appreciate in Carmack’s performance.) He’s also the father of her child. And Jo’s children. There’s so much for Grey’s Anatomy to explore here, and I hope that it doesn’t skip over it.
After all, everything with the VIP floor is also a testament to what Grey’s Anatomy can accomplish with consistency. “Till I Collapse” completely earns everything from Bailey raiding the Olympic floor’s supply closet to Webber taking a stand and doing what’s right for the patients. There are ripples to that. For example, Catherine may have to fire her husband if she stands by her and Norton’s work.
Most importantly, though, it’s a positive step to ensure that Grey Sloan Memorial doesn’t let another patient slip through the cracks. There are a lot of questions this season about whether the hospital is still as great as it once was. Webber making this risky choice for the health of the patients rather than the health of the hospital’s pockets proves that it is. Grey Sloan is not perfect. It may be even less so with the fallout of this, but it’s doing its best in a broken system.
MORE: Grey’s Anatomy Season 23, Episode 3 Review: “Our Lives Are Full of Mysteries”
—