We’re back! Eternally Yours Season 1 Episode 7 ‘Jesse’s Girl,’ shows us the aftermath of the previous episode’s events. It serves as a trial by fire for Jesse and Phyllis, while Emma teaches Max a lesson. Ready?
Here we go!
Phyllis Has Every Reason to Question Jesse’s Love

We didn’t think it was possible to love Jesse and Phyllis even more, but Eternally YoursSeason 1 Episode 7 ‘Jesse’s Girl,’ proved us wrong. Phyllis had to face the reality that her entire family consists of vampires—and that they had kept this from her. Yet, she still comes down from her room, calm and willing to listen. Honestly, we don’t think we could have shown that much composure.
It’s only natural for Phyllis to feel foolish. How could she not have known? But learning that Jesse had been playing with her mind, manipulating her, was the final straw. And we said it. We said that makes everything so much worse. It’s no longer just about them hiding a massive secret from her. It’s about her entire life being a lie.
If Jesse was manipulating Phyllis mind the whole time, what is actually real? What is she to Jesse? In Eternally Yours Season 1 Episode 7 ‘Jesse’s Girl,’ Phyllis feels like nothing more than a toy—a form of entertainment to pass the time until the next one comes along—all while he manipulates her mind so she can never truly know him. We know that couldn’t be further from the truth, but it’s perfectly logical for Phyllis to question everything she thought she knew, including Jesse’s love for her.
And words aren’t enough. Jesse needs to find a way to show Phyllis just how important she is to him. And he does. Nine previous wives. Nine. Jesse never wanted to tell any of them the truth. It never even crossed his mind. But with Phyllis… with her, it’s different. He wants her to know him—everything about him.
And yes, it took him a long time because he was afraid of losing her along the way, but he finally did it. In Eternally Yours Season 1 Episode 7 ‘Jesse’s Girl,’ he finally revealed his true self to her—fangs and all. He truly wants her to know who he really is, even if it means losing her forever. That speaks volumes about what Phyllis means to him. We love them so much!
On another note, in Eternally Yours Season 1 Episode 7 ‘Jesse’s Girl,’ Max got a taste of what Emma is like when she’s annoyed. We don’t feel the least bit sorry for him, though—he had it coming. It’s one thing to be really invested in your classes and act like a bit of a know-it-all, but it’s quite another to try and teach someone how to do something they’ve been doing for 200 years.
That’s just arrogance and mansplaining. Emma had to take him down a peg, so good for her! Though, playing devil’s advocate for a moment, it was perhaps a bit cruel to have everyone laugh at him. That said—seriously, Max, how could you fall for that? “Harry Potter is real”—really? Come on, man, we can’t defend that! The best part, though, is that our little know-it-all chose the perfect moment to make his entrance. It couldn’t have been better!
MORE: Allegra Edwards on the Side of Liz We Haven’t Seen Yet in Eternally Yours
Other Thoughts on Eternally Yours Season 1 Episode 7

- What a way to meet the love of your life!
- Nine wives!
- What a kiss, Phyllis!
- Phyllis’s friends are the best… even if they are a bit stingy. LMAO.
- Now that Phyllis knows the truth, will Jesse turn her into a vampire?
- Phyllis needs to talk to her kids!
- Customer service is always the worst—vampiric or otherwise.
- Max, we love you, your innocence is just so cute!
- A family will always come together to save one of its own.
Eternally Yours Season 1 airs on Thursdays at 8:30 PM ET on CBS.