Spilled Milk feels like a modern tale that could fit right in with Grimm’s Fairy Tales.
It tells the story of a young man who continues seeking out his deadbeat father who went to the store to get milk and never came back. And when he ends up finding him, a tense encounter turns into a terrifying one where a villain is presented, family dynamics explode, and something common to all of us turns into something to fear.
Personally I love a good horror short. I always believe that with less time, the crew of a short film has to work 10 times as hard to deliver a specific message. And in Spilled Milk I was able to understand the lead Trey down to his very bones. I could feel his anger, mounting loss, and hurt because of what happened with his father. But I could also feel this desperation to know why his father left him, even if that meant not coming home to his family first.
MORE: Coax Review: Connor Storrie’s Short Film is Terrifying
The confrontation that Trey has with his father Marcus is also really layered. Because we don’t know 100% what happened to the dad. But we do know that when they reunite, he cares enough to want to get his son out of there, even if it means a confrontation. That’s where The Milk Man comes in. He’s the villain of the story. And even though we don’t get concrete answers as to who he is, he’s clever and dangerous. He also knows how to manipulate vulnerable people like Trey and probably Marcus.
When you put all these elements together, you get a cautionary tale about holding on to the past and the pain that it can bring you. Because you could see Trey molding himself into someone who wasn’t like his father. But in his hunt for answers, and of course because of The Milk Man, he became like his father. So Spilled Milk is about unexplainable evils that tear families apart but also how it echoes into the lives of those left behind. But also it’s about the choices that those family members make in the after.
MORE: Miss Ophelia Lovibond and Jacob Anderson on your screen? Read our review for Still Life!
Going back to what I said in the title about Spilled Milk being a terrifying twist to a modern tale. Everything in our lives are stories. One of those stories or tales is the one about a father who says he’s going out for milk and who never comes back. And I feel like the director Jaref Leaf took that and built a world with lore, an absolutely undeniable splash of magic, and a wickedness that feels like it’s from a fairy tale. And that kind of evolution to a story that I heard time and time again growing up, is the kind of magic that I want to see in film.
Also, sidebar, I know everyone is going to talk about the Jordan Peele of it all. He’s an executive producer on this. But Spilled Milk absolutely shined because of J. Alphonse Nicholson’s Trey, Rodney Van Johnson’s Marcus, and Jerry O’Connell’s The Milk Man. We also got a little surprise for the eagle-eyed viewer because that was Brandon Perea from The OA playing Jose. And then you have Kid Cudi himself aka Scott Mescuti as Barry. Basically, Spilled Milk is a terrifying delight from top to bottom and I need a feature film asap.
MORE: The Whistler Review: This Indie Film Is More Vibes Than Jump Scares
Spilled Milk is screening at the 2026 HollyShorts Film Festival.
