The relationships that get to me most aren’t always the ones where two people have to figure out whether they love each other. Sometimes, they’re the ones where the love is already there, but someone doesn’t quite know how to trust it.
That’s what broke my heart about Forgotten Holiday. Kathryn loves Rob. That isn’t the question. The question is whether she can let herself believe in a future with him without spending every happy moment preparing for it to end.
And watching her struggle with that felt a little too personal.
I am always the first to tell anyone that I’m a Grinch. I don’t like Christmas. The truth is that the holiday holds a lot of bad memories for me—the kind that find their way back every year, no matter how much I wish they wouldn’t.
And yet, every year, there I am watching Countdown to Christmas. Getting invested in people falling in love beneath twinkling lights. Wondering whether the ice around my heart might finally be melting.
Maybe my heart has grown a little bigger.
Maybe.
But in all my Hallmark movie watching, I don’t think I’ve ever cried as hard as I did watching Forgotten Holiday. This wasn’t a few tears I could wipe away and blame on being tired. Somewhere inside Kathryn and Rob’s story, the movie found something I usually keep tucked away.
Something about wanting to be loved while being terrified of what happens once you let yourself need it.
RELATED: Brendan Penny on Mr. & Mrs. Christmas and the People Who Make Hallmark Feel Like Family
Loving Someone Isn’t the Same as Feeling Safe
There’s a moment when Kathryn, played by Janel Parrish, talks about spending her adult life waiting for things to disappear. In her experience, even the things that are supposed to be permanent break.
And, well. That’s me.
That’s the thought that can sit quietly beneath an otherwise happy moment. Don’t get too comfortable and don’t need this too much. Don’t start imagining a future you might eventually have to grieve.
Hearing Kathryn express that fear made me feel seen in a way I wasn’t prepared for. Because she isn’t someone who doesn’t want love. She wants it. She has it with Rob, played by Daniel Lissing. What she struggles with is believing that she can settle into that happiness without leaving herself defenseless.
The movie’s emotional weight comes from that. Rob’s love can be sincere, and Kathryn can still be frightened. He can offer reassurance without knowing how deeply her fear runs. Neither of them has to be lying about what they feel for there to be something painful between them.
That’s what makes their relationship worth investing in. The obstacle isn’t a lack of affection. It’s everything Kathryn has learned to expect from people, following her into a relationship she desperately wants to keep.
RELATED: Mr & Mrs Christmas Review: You Can’t Force The Holidays, You Have To Find Them
The Pressure of Being Someone’s Perfect Person
Kathryn and Rob meet at an antiques market where she outbids him on a movie projector and is a little cocky about her victory. Rather than being put off, he finds a reason to keep talking to her. She knows antiques. He restores things. There’s an easy romantic appeal to two people connecting over objects someone else might have overlooked.
I also love the way that beginning fits the larger story. Their work asks them to see value in things with a past. But appreciating an object’s history is easier than letting another person see your own.
We don’t spend much time with their relationship before the accident, but one early exchange stayed with me: Rob keeps telling Kathryn she’s perfect.
I know he means it lovingly. He sees the woman he wants to build a life with, and he wants her to understand how much he adores her. There’s sweetness in his certainty.
But I felt for her, too.
Because being someone’s perfect person can feel like pressure when you’re already afraid that being fully known will change how they see you.
What happens when you disappoint them? When you’re scared in a way they don’t understand? When they ask you the question you’re supposed to be thrilled to answer, and you freeze?
Rob looks at their relationship and sees a future. Kathryn sees that future, too, but she also sees everything she could lose.
THE PROPOSAL
When he proposes and she runs without answering, I hurt for both of them. For him, because offering someone your heart and watching them leave is devastating. For her, because I don’t see a woman who doesn’t care. I see someone whose fear has gotten ahead of what she wants.
Understanding her doesn’t make the hurt she causes disappear. That matters. The movie gives us room to feel compassion for Kathryn without asking us to pretend Rob’s heartbreak is less important.
Then, on his way to his sister’s house, Rob has a car accident. He loses his memories of the past year.
He forgets Kathryn.
And suddenly, she’s the only one carrying the history of their relationship—including the moment she’s afraid to explain.
A Second Chance With Something Left Unsaid
There’s something both romantic and heartbreaking about getting another chance with someone who doesn’t remember the first one.
When the doctor suggests that Kathryn and Rob date again, she agrees because she loves him. Of course she wants to help him remember. Of course she wants the familiarity of being with someone who knows her, someone whose feelings she didn’t have to question.
But he doesn’t remember the proposal. He doesn’t remember her leaving.
For now, she gets to be close to him without facing that conversation, and I understand why she wants to hold onto it. How do you tell someone you love that the last time they offered you a future, you ran? Especially when you haven’t fully figured out why?
That secret changes the texture of their romance. A sweet moment can be genuinely sweet and still carry an undercurrent of dread. Kathryn knows something that could hurt him, and every step toward recovering their past brings them closer to it.
I don’t think her silence has to mean she’s deliberately trying to deceive him for it to become a problem. Fear can make withholding the truth feel like protecting something fragile. But the longer she avoids it, the harder it becomes to separate protecting the relationship from protecting herself.
That’s where her growth needs to happen. She can’t simply recover the version of their relationship that existed before the accident and hope the same fear won’t return. She has to understand why she ran—and find a way to tell Rob that doesn’t leave him guessing whether she loves him.
There’s a vulnerability in that which feels more meaningful to me than any grand declaration. Kathryn needs to let him see the part of her she’s least confident he’ll understand.
Finding Each Other Without Losing Themselves
As much as I want Rob to remember Kathryn, I also want him to have room to figure out who he is now.
That’s the delicate part of this premise. Everyone else has a history with him that he can’t fully access. Kathryn knows what they meant to each other, but knowing that they were in love isn’t the same as him feeling it for himself.
Their second chance works best for me when it feels like an opportunity to discover each other rather than an obligation to recreate what came before. I want their memories to matter. I also want the moments they’re sharing now to have value beyond whether they trigger something from the past.
Because there is romance in getting to know someone again. In paying attention. In finding reasons to enjoy their company when familiarity can no longer do all the work.
For Kathryn, that means facing the possibility that she can’t control the outcome, no matter how much she loves him. For Rob, it means having the space to respond honestly rather than being expected to step back into a relationship everyone else remembers.
Their journey becomes more moving when both of those needs matter. She deserves the chance to be understood. He deserves the truth and the freedom to decide what it means to him.
I’m rooting for them because I want them to reach a place where neither has to hide—or pretend—to keep the other close.
RELATED: ‘Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story’ Review: It’s Not So Much The Football, It Is The Community It Brings
Janel Parrish Makes Kathryn’s Fear Feel Personal
I’ve enjoyed Janel Parrish in so many projects, but there’s something about this performance that feels especially vulnerable.
So much of Kathryn’s uncertainty lives in her eyes. Even when she’s beside the person she wants to be with, Parrish gives her this watchfulness, as though she’s trying to work out whether she’s allowed to relax.
I know that feeling. I wish I didn’t, but I do.
What gets to me is how clearly Parrish lets us see Kathryn wanting closeness. Her guardedness doesn’t erase her affection. Sometimes it makes that affection hurt more, because we can see how much she stands to lose and how little faith she has in her ability to survive losing it.
That keeps Kathryn from becoming someone I’m simply frustrated with. Yes, I want her to stop running. I want her to be honest. But I also want her to understand herself well enough to make a different choice, rather than just say the right thing because she’s afraid Rob will leave.
There were moments when I wanted to reach through the screen and hug her. Tell her that she doesn’t have to have everything figured out to be loved.
And then I wanted to thank Parrish for making that feeling so recognizable.
Her performance gives weight to the possibility of learning to feel safe with someone again. It doesn’t make that possibility look easy. It makes it look worth trying for.
Daniel Lissing Gives Us a Rob We Have to Rediscover
Daniel Lissing remains one of those actors I watch and immediately wish would do more projects. I enjoy him onscreen, and this role asks him to make Rob feel familiar and unfamiliar at the same time.
Before the accident, Rob has a confidence about Kathryn and their future. Afterward, Lissing gives us someone distinctly different.
I’ll admit that the extent of the change confused me at times. I didn’t always understand why the contrast needed to feel quite so pronounced. There were moments when I was trying to reconcile the two versions of Rob rather than simply settling into his story.
But I can question that choice and still appreciate what Lissing accomplishes within it. He makes the difference clear enough that Kathryn’s loneliness becomes understandable. The person she loves is standing in front of her, but the ease they once shared is no longer something she can reach for and expect him to recognize.
Parrish and Lissing make that distance hurt. They also give their scenes together a tenderness that keeps me invested in what could come next. There has to be more than just an explanation or a restored memory. I want them to feel comfortable with each other again. I want the affection Kathryn remembers to become something they can both experience in the present.
A Little Room for Hope
Watching Kathryn and Rob find their way back to each other felt therapeutic.
I don’t mean that their story fixed anything for me. Christmas still carries memories I would rather not revisit. One movie doesn’t undo that, and I wouldn’t want to pretend it does.
But Forgotten Holiday gave me room to feel something else alongside the hurt.
The warmth of family. The romance of choosing to stay curious about someone you love. The relief of seeing a character wrestle with a fear you’ve struggled to put into words—and watching her begin to find a way through it.
For a little while, I wasn’t just waiting for the season to be over. I was letting myself enjoy something about it.
By the time Kathryn and Rob find their way to each other, I’m invested in more than whether they’ll end up together. I care about whether Kathryn can let herself be known. Whether the truth can become part of their relationship instead of something threatening it from the outside. Whether they can make room for the people they actually are, rather than the people they think they need to be.
That’s what makes their happiness emotional for me. It comes with a better understanding of themselves and each other.
AND SO…
And maybe that’s why this movie hit me as hard as it did. I recognized Kathryn’s instinct to brace for loss. Watching her reach for something beyond that made me wonder whether I could, too.
So, Countdown to Christmas, you got me with this one.
You made this self-proclaimed Grinch cry, feel, and want to believe in something again. I’m thankful for that, even if I’m still a little annoyed about how many tissues it took.
Now excuse me while I go watch it again.
Bring on the tears. At least this time, I know they’re coming.
