SPOILER ALERT AND WARNING: The following contains spoilers for CIA Season 2, Episode 7. It also contains discussion of suicide.
CIA Season 2, Episode 7 is unquestionably a filler episode. “Inside Men” is mostly about showing viewers that both Bill Goodman and Colin Glass are not okay after the previous hour’s big plot twists, and getting to the point where Bill reveals he has Felix Vincente held captive. The case of the week is mostly a way for the CBS spinoff to get those ideas across.
Said investigation involves Bill and Colin infiltrating a Robin Hood-esque activist group that wants to steal from (or kill) the rich in order to help the poor. The most interesting thing about this plotline is that John, one of the group’s two leaders, is played by former Law & Order: SVU star Octavio Pisano. Otherwise, it pretty much goes by the numbers. Colin forms a bond with the other leader Maya, who opens up to him about how she founded the group after her family fell on hard times and her father took his own life. This paves the way for Maya to help Bill and Colin when John goes rogue, and for the expected scene where she’s hurt when she finds out that Colin lied to her. The plot moves at a steady pace, but the audience will mostly know where it’s going.

The undercover element also minimizes the screen time for Nikki Reynard and Gina Gosian. Nikki has an early scene where she checks in with Colin to briefly discuss Toni Napier’s transfer; that too is easy to call, as he claims he’s fine and she doesn’t entirely believe him. But Nikki and Gina spend the episode looking for Bill and Colin, and then helping them from afar. This is really a two-hander episode for Nick Gehlfuss and Tom Ellis, with the former still playing Bill as edgy as he was at the end of Episode 6. It doesn’t take a CIA agent to know there’s something wrong with Bill. And while it’s fun from an acting standpoint to see Gehlfuss continue to break that straight-laced mold, there’s only so much mileage CIA can get out of Colin questioning his partner.
Pisano is the scene-stealer here, in part because John is obviously a totally different character than his SVU detective Joe Velasco. It’s also fun to see him play a clear villain. That means he gets the showiest scenes, as John goes through all the “loose cannon” character beats, from being the most skeptical of the new arrivals, to shooting one of his own men (who happens to be one of Maya’s relatives), to making a big speech about how he doesn’t want to surrender. John is the most interesting of the guest players, even though Maya is supposed to be the more prominent character. (At least CIA doesn’t try to shoehorn in her and Colin becoming impulsively romantically involved, which would not only be cliche but make little sense given that viewers are supposed to believe he’s still thinking about Toni.)
Ellis and Gehlfuss are as reliable as ever here, but especially after all that the prior episode spilled out onto the table, “Inside Men” is a letdown. It utilizes very little of the momentum created by “Legacy.” It’s important that Bill comes clean to Colin about Vincente—not only because of the dramatic tension that creates, but because it’d be hard to believe that Bill could keep such a major secret from Colin for so long, given how much better Colin is at their job. But beyond that, there aren’t even really memorable moments for either of them in this episode. Colin’s bond with Maya doesn’t feel that deep, despite Ellis’ best efforts performance-wise, and Bill just banters with the CIA employee responsible for setting up their cover identities. He doesn’t even get any information out of Vincente, at least not yet.
The Achilles heel of CIA has been that sometimes, the episodes are driven by the show’s guest stars, rather than the main cast. “Inside Men” is another example of that, simply because Octavio Pisano has more attention-grabbing scenes than either Ellis or Gehlfuss. Characters like John are why some actors say it’s more fun to play the bad guy. And not every episode has to have a major revelation in it, especially not on network TV, which has far larger episode orders to fill.
But CIA still has to give the viewers something, and Episode 7 doesn’t offer much reward. It doesn’t take full advantage of the previous episode’s cliffhanger, and its case of the week is profoundly average. It wants to get inside Colin and Bill’s heads, but even that sort of happens in passing. CIA Season 2 still feels like the best is yet to come.
CIA airs Mondays at 9:00 p.m. ET/PT on CBS. Photo Credit: Courtesy of CBS.