Tradition.
When you sit down and think about the traditions in your life, what comes to mind first? For me, it’s baking cookies in my grandma’s kitchen. She’d sit us at the round table in the corner and remind us that we were there to decorate, not eat.
As if sampling the frosting wasn’t an essential part of the process.
That was Christmas to me. That kitchen. That table. The feeling of knowing exactly where you belonged without ever having to question it.
But getting older has a way of changing your relationship with the things you thought would always feel the same. Traditions shift. People do, too. Somewhere along the way, my Grinch heart took over, and Christmas started meaning less and less to me.
What I didn’t expect was to find my way back through a different tradition: watching Hallmark’s Countdown to Christmas religiously.
And yes, I know. There’s a formula. There are familiar setups and moments when you can practically predict what someone will say before they open their mouth. I am not here to argue with any of that. I am here to tell you that knowing a love story is probably going to end happily does not make me any less invested in how these two people get there.
Sometimes, that certainty is part of the appeal. I want something to look forward to. I want to care entirely too much about fictional people finding love while surrounded by an unreasonable amount of Christmas greenery. Let me have this.
It’s movies like Our Holiday Playbook that remind me why I make the time.
THE SETUP
The setup had my attention immediately: Lexi Bell comes home for Christmas and finds herself pulled back into the Bell Bowl, her family’s annual flag football game and the centerpiece of a decades-long rivalry between her father and uncle. When her brother-in-law’s injury leaves the team short a player, former local football star turned teacher Eddie offers a very convenient possibility.
There’s just one little eligibility issue. He needs to be family—or at least close enough to pass as Lexi’s boyfriend.
Their arrangement gives them both something they want: Eddie will help her family chase a win, and Lexi will help him take on his brother in their annual bake-off.
Fake dating AND holiday baking? Fine. You have my attention. You probably could have stopped at fake dating, but I appreciate the commitment to my interests.
What makes the premise worth investing in, though, is that Lexi isn’t simply desperate to win a football game. She’s trying to make disappointing her father hurt less.
And that is a very different kind of pressure.
THE DEAL
Lexi loves being a lawyer. What she doesn’t love is the future her father has seemingly mapped out for her at his firm, working in tax law. Coming home has put her in the uncomfortable position of knowing what she doesn’t want without knowing how to tell someone she loves.
So the Bell Bowl becomes a bargaining chip. Maybe if she helps deliver the trophy he wants so badly, telling him she wants a different career path won’t feel quite so devastating.
Oh, Lexi. The fact that you think you need to earn the right to have that conversation? That’s the part that gets me.
There’s something painfully recognizable about trying to soften a boundary with an achievement. About thinking that if you can be a good enough daughter in one area, you’ll be allowed to make your own choices in another. Lexi’s investment in winning isn’t really about suddenly embracing the family rivalry. It’s about managing her father’s feelings before she gives herself permission to acknowledge her own.
That gives the movie’s focus on tradition a little more weight. The Bell Bowl may bring the family together, but togetherness doesn’t automatically mean everyone is enjoying the same experience. For her father, it’s a chance to finally win. For Lexi, it’s another place where she feels responsible for making him happy.
RESPONSIBILITY
And loving your family should not require turning every part of your life into proof that you haven’t let them down.
That’s the thread I appreciate here. Beneath the holiday competition and fake-boyfriend arrangement is a woman trying to figure out how to stay close to her family without surrendering the life she actually wants. She doesn’t need to stop loving her father. She needs to be able to disagree with him without treating it as a failure of that love.
Of course, all of this emotional baggage arrives with a romantic distraction, and I am only human.
Enter Eddie, whose introduction involves shoveling snow directly into Lexi’s path because apparently paying attention to his surroundings was not on his Christmas list.
Is getting hit with flying snow how I would personally choose to meet a man? No. Would I enjoy watching him try to charm his way back from that first impression? Absolutely.
You’ve made an impression, sir. Now let’s see what you do with it.
The thing is, Eddie follows up on that first impression. When he sees Lexi again at a Christmas market, he asks her out, and her sister encourages her to give him a chance.
I love a sister who wants you to have a life outside of managing everyone else’s expectations. Someone needs to be looking out for Lexi’s happiness, especially when Lexi herself keeps moving it down her list of priorities.
DATING
Unfortunately, having someone in your corner does not guarantee a successful date.
Because this one? A disaster.
The kind where you reach for your phone and request an emergency rescue, only to discover that you’ve accidentally sent the text to the person you’re trying to escape.
I was watching through my fingers. Lexi, PLEASE. There is no casually looking at the Christmas decorations and pretending that didn’t happen.
But Eddie’s response matters more than the embarrassment. He takes it well. His pride doesn’t turn an uncomfortable moment into something cruel, and that gives us a reason to stay interested even when their evening isn’t exactly making a case for a second date. A man can recover from an awkward night. Making a woman feel terrible because she isn’t having a good time would be considerably harder to come back from.
ARRANGEMENTS
Their arrangement gives them a way past that disastrous beginning. Lexi needs his football skills, and Eddie desperately needs her baking expertise if he’s ever going to beat his brother. Suddenly, they have something to do besides sit across from each other and try to manufacture a connection.
And THAT is where I started rooting for them.
There’s a difference between trying to impress someone and letting them get to know you. When these two stop putting so much pressure on the first part, the second becomes possible. They can tease each other. Learn from each other. Discover what’s underneath the nerves and the family competitiveness.
Watching them settle into that comfort made me think about how quickly I’ve sometimes decided that an awkward interaction told me everything I needed to know about a person. How many times have I mistaken nerves for a lack of connection? How often have I wanted grace for my own terrible first impression without remembering to extend it to someone else?
Not every bad date deserves another chance. But I appreciate a romance that leaves room for the possibility that people are more interesting—and more lovable—than their least charming hour.
THE DATE
Eddie and Lexi don’t become compelling because their first date secretly wasn’t that bad. They become compelling because we get to see what happens afterward.
The more comfortable they become with each other, the more their arrangement exposes the things they aren’t comfortable admitting at home. They can recognize the pressure in each other’s family dynamics more easily than they can confront it in their own. Helping someone else win feels manageable. Admitting why winning matters so much is considerably harder.
And there’s something deliciously messy about watching two people develop a genuinely honest connection while being decidedly less than honest about why they’re together.
Yes, I will happily enjoy the fake-dating setup. I will take the proximity, the blurred lines, and every moment when pretending starts requiring suspiciously little effort. But I also need the movie to acknowledge that finding a convenient interpretation of the rules doesn’t magically make the deception disappear.
Lexi and Eddie can justify the arrangement to themselves. That doesn’t mean they feel good about it.
WINNING
Eventually, winning would mean accepting a victory built on something they haven’t been willing to tell their families. That puts a limit on how satisfying either competition can be. What is the trophy actually worth if getting it leaves you more anxious about being honest than you were before?
Neither of them needs another reason to measure their place in the family by whether they can finally deliver a win. They need room to lose without feeling lesser. Room to want something different. Room to believe that being loved isn’t contingent on being useful to the team.
That’s what makes their growing connection satisfying to me. The romance isn’t separate from the family story; it helps bring that story into focus. As they become more at ease together, it gets harder to ignore how much effort they’ve been putting into meeting everyone else’s expectations.
And that brings Our Holiday Playbook back to what drew me in at the beginning: tradition.
THE TRADITION
The football and baking competitions give everyone a reason to gather, but gathering should be the point. Somewhere along the way, beating each other has started taking up more space than enjoying each other. A tradition can be meaningful and still need adjusting. Keeping it alive shouldn’t require everyone to keep playing the same role forever.
That feels especially meaningful in a Countdown to Christmas movie, because familiarity is part of what I come here for. I want the holiday rituals. I want the romance. I want that feeling of returning to something I love. But within that familiarity, I also want characters who get to move forward.
Lexi and Eddie don’t need entirely new personalities to find happiness. They need to grow comfortable enough with themselves to stop treating honesty as something that threatens their relationships.
There’s a difference between changing who you are to make someone happy and growing into someone who can finally say what you need. This romance gives me a reason to care about the latter.
HOLIDAY FEELINGS
The holidays can put so much pressure on us to recreate a feeling, whether or not the traditions attached to it still fit. We want things to be how they were. We want everyone to be happy. And sometimes we get so caught up in preserving the experience that we forget to ask whether we’re actually enjoying it.
I started watching these movies as a new tradition when the old feeling of Christmas had become harder to find. So yes, a story about making room for something different was going to get to me.
I still miss that round table in my grandma’s kitchen. I still carry what it meant to me. But there’s room for the traditions I’m building now, too—and for the person I’ve become since I sat there, sneaking frosting when I was supposed to be decorating.