The holiday season looks a little different for everyone, but for me, it always comes back to tradition. Putting up the Christmas tree. Making the meals you look forward to all year. Finding a gift you can’t wait to give someone. Spending time with the people who make this time of year feel special.
And, of course, making sure I am firmly planted on the couch for every Countdown to Christmas movie. That’s a tradition, too, and I take it seriously.
Sometimes, I still have to pinch myself knowing I get to talk to the people who make these movies. Growing up, I was an awkward girl from the Midwest who didn’t dare imagine that interviewing actors would ever be part of her life. Getting to sit down with Taylor Cole and Charles Michael Davis? That’s one of those moments when I wish I could tell my younger self what was ahead.
If you’ve been around Fangirlish for a while, you know we loved our CW shows. The Vampire Diaries. The Originals. We were there, invested and emotionally attached. So, yes, talking to Davis meant giving my inner fangirl a moment before remembering that I had questions to ask.
Was I a little embarrassed by my own excitement? Absolutely. But there’s something to be said for letting yourself enjoy the moments you once wouldn’t have thought possible.
Cole and Davis star in tonight’s Countdown to Christmas movie, Our Holiday Playbook, which brings together family traditions, a little competitive spirit, and a fake relationship that might not stay fake for long.
A Little Football, a Little Fake Dating
The film follows Lexi Bell, who returns home for the holidays to face a family tradition she would rather avoid: the Bell Bowl. The annual Christmas flag football game pits her father against her uncle in a rivalry decades in the making.
When an injury sidelines her brother-in-law, another loss seems inevitable. Enter Eddie (Davis), a former local football star turned teacher, and a deal that could benefit them both. Lexi will help Eddie beat his brother in their annual bake-off if he agrees to pose as her boyfriend, making him eligible to play on her family’s team.
Of course, spending the holidays together means navigating more than a football game. Between family gatherings, festive traditions, and the effort of selling their supposed romance, Lexi and Eddie begin to discover that their connection might be more genuine than either expected.
Fake dating and holiday baking? I’m already interested. Add two leads I was excited to talk to, and this one has my attention.
The football angle also caught my interest, especially with the Holiday Touchdown movies in mind. Naturally, I wanted to know which of them had the better flag football skills.
Davis was quick to give Cole credit.
“You were surprisingly good, though. You don’t drop a pass unless it was scripted.”
Cole agreed, but she wasn’t about to let him downplay his own abilities.
“That’s true. That’s true. But his arm, he’s got a really, really good arm,” she said, before admitting, “I am a terrible runner, but I do have hand eye coordination.”
Ultimately, she was happy to hand Davis the win, adding, “But I’d say I’d say as far as agility for flag football goes, I’m going to give him the trophy for sure. Yeah, you win.”
What stood out to Cole, though, wasn’t simply the competition on the field.
“But really, it’s about family traditions, right?”
And that was exactly what I wanted to talk about next.
A Holiday Competition Worth Borrowing
There’s something special about the traditions that belong to your family—the things you look forward to every year because the holidays wouldn’t feel quite the same without them. With those rituals playing such a big role in Our Holiday Playbook, I wanted to know which ones Cole and Davis treasure in their own lives.
Cole’s smile said plenty before she even began describing hers.
“Well, my husband picks out a cookie cutter and we send it to all of the families all over the United States. And so everybody has the same cookie cutter. We bake the cookies. And on Christmas Eve, everybody decorates their cookies. We take pictures of them and then we post them on my Instagram and people vote for them.”
A family cookie-decorating competition that lets everyone participate, even from different parts of the country? That is exactly the kind of holiday tradition I can get behind.
Although, according to Cole, the competition does have a fairly predictable outcome. Her husband’s sister’s family brings the artistic talent, while the rest of the family brings enthusiasm.
“And we’re all just kind of there for fun because our cookies are juvenile and rudimentary. But it is so fun to watch them succeed and us fail. So it’s really fun.”
Honestly, that might be my favorite part. Everyone knows who will probably win, and everyone keeps showing up anyway. It’s less about creating a perfect cookie than having something to share, laugh about, and look forward to together.
I liked the idea enough that I’ve already ordered cookie cutters to try it myself. Consider this one a tradition I’m happily borrowing.
Dinner and a Holiday Favorite
Davis’s holiday tradition is a little simpler, but no less appealing.
“We mostly we’ll eat and then we’ll watch a film.”
The movie of choice? Home Alone.
Honestly, that sounds like a pretty great holiday evening to me. A good meal, a favorite movie, and time together. Not every tradition needs a competition or an elaborate plan to be worth keeping.
That’s part of what makes me excited to watch Our Holiday Playbook. The fake-dating setup sounds fun, and I’m looking forward to seeing Cole and Davis together on screen, but I’m just as interested in the family dynamics surrounding their characters. The rivalries, the rituals, the gatherings you wouldn’t miss—even when your family is taking a Christmas flag football game far too seriously.
I’ll be on the couch for this one. Some traditions are worth protecting.
Our Holiday Playbook premieres tonight as part of Countdown to Christmas.