We’re back! Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow,’ finds Colum at his most vulnerable moment, while Jocasta plays a dangerous game that could backfire at any moment, and Ellen begins to build her life with Brian. Ready?
Here we go!
The Mackenzies Have a Lot More to Lose

Colum suffers a big loss in Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow.’ When we saw this in Outlander, it seemed horrific—a superstition that leads to leaving a baby out in the elements… inevitably resulting in its death. It created a brutal contrast between Claire’s logic, her desperate attempt to save the child and the belief that such an act was actually a kindness, done out of love for the child.
Seeing it again in Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow,’ it provided an insight we previously lacked, helping us better understand the context. That said, it was still heartbreaking to see the baby die, in a sense, at the hands of its own parents.
We just wanted to scream: “Forget the fairies, just love the baby, and that’s that!” Of course, we can understand why Colum and Letitia want to do anything to change that fate.
Regardless, it’s clear that Colum is consumed by guilt in Outlander: Blood of My BloodSeason 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow.’ Part of him is convinced that his son was born with a deformity because of him. And, honestly, we just wanted to give him a hug and tell him that it wasn’t his fault—and that there was nothing wrong with either him or the baby. But things are not that simple.
Colum knows that he has to put in twice the effort to earn people’s respect and be seen as a proper laird, all because of his leg. And the frustrating part is that he’s not imagining things. There are still plenty of people who question whether he has what it takes to lead the clan simply because of his disability.
It’s something he has endured his entire life, so when his first child is born with a deformity, he knows what lies ahead. And it’s only logical that he would blame himself. He feels there is something inherently wrong or “defective” about him—a sentiment everyone around him has always reinforced—and he fears he has passed this on to his own offspring.
That couldn’t be further from the truth, but we can understand why Colum makes the decision he does about his marriage to Letitia in Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow.’ After all, we already know how things turn out in Outlander. Colum and Letitia never have children together, and the boy Colum raises as his own is actually Dougal’s son. Everything seems to be heading in that direction, and if we’re right, we’re in for quite a dramatic turn of events!
Speaking of Dougal, Maura is pregnant. Again, since we know they have no children in Outlander, we’re left wondering what will become of this baby—and whether this might be the catalyst that drives them to become the fractured couple we recognize from the original series.
That said, there is another thing to consider: the clan. With Colum determined to have no more children and Maura pregnant, will Dougal push for a change in leadership, or will he remain loyal to his brother—despite his and Maura’s own hunger for power? Interesting…
MORE: Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2, Episode 8 Review: Lovat’s Dangerous Game
Jocasta May Have Just Made a Terrible Mistake

The stars aligned in Jocasta’s favor in Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow.’ Murtagh killed John’s pig—albeit by accident—and that puts him in serious danger. Him, and Grace, too. If anyone suspects what happened, both of them will be hanged. And Jocasta, being a true MacKenzie, manages to turn the situation to her advantage.
Although Jocasta doesn’t particularly care for Grace, she loves Murtagh, and she has no intention of letting him end up dead because of what happened. So, in one sense, Jocasta genuinely wants to help. But, as is often the case with the MacKenzies, there’s more to it. It likely wasn’t strictly necessary for Grace to go far away and leave Murtagh behind in order for them to escape. They could have run off together.
Nevertheless, Jocasta finds herself in a privileged position in Outlander: Blood of My BloodSeason 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow.’ She can help Murtagh and let him leave with Grace… or she can help him while ensuring he is separated from her forever. If Jocasta chooses the first option, she loses Murtagh for good.
But, if she chooses the second… she might be able to win him back, given time. If she chooses the second option, they might even be able to pick up where they left off that one night. And that is what Jocasta wants most than anything.
So, Jocasta chooses the second option. Was it selfish? Absolutely. And a little cruel, too. But honestly, can we really blame her? We may not like to say it out loud, but there’s a good chance many of us would have made the exact same choice in her position. The temptation was simply too hard to resist.
And so, in Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow,’ Jocasta feels a sense of newfound freedom. With John out of the picture and Grace far away, she could win back Murtagh while enjoying her own liberty. She can live in her own terms. But she hadn’t accounted for Hugh Cameron. Honestly, it’s hard to say which brother is worse. It must be in their blood, because only a degenerate would force his own sister-in-law to marry him.
The very same woman who, until 5 minutes ago, was his brother’s wife—and who, he knows, is hiding something regarding his death. How long has he been coveting Jocasta? It’s disgusting! We don’t even have the words for this. And the worst part is that Jocasta has no choice but to agree. If she refuses, Murtagh’s life—as well as her own—will be in danger, because Hugh wouldn’t hesitate to drag her into the whole mess.
In Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow,’ Jocasta is back in a position where other people get to decide what happens to her and where her life goes. She had barely had a chance to enjoy that little taste of freedom before it was taken away from her. It’s so unfair!
Sometimes, Family Finds Its Way Back

Ned Gowan earned his place in heaven in Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow.’ First, he was there for Colum and later, he tried to help Colum and Ellen bridge the gap between them. And, truth be told, Colum’s gesture is a good start. By giving her their mother’s wedding dress and ring, he’s signaling his support and approval.
Don’t get us wrong, Ellen neither needs nor seeks Colum’s approval. But she and Brian had to defy everyone and everything to be together. Even the land where they plan to build their home is something they had to fight for. They’ve had to forge their life together, knowing that doing so meant losing their families.
The wedding dress and ring belong to Ellen. They’re items her parents would have given her for a wedding celebrated by her entire family. By offering them now, Colum is conveying that her marriage to Brian doesn’t change the fact that he is her brother, and that he is happy for her. Furthermore, it serves as an olive branch—an apology for his past wrongs—and an attempt at reconciliation.
And we can’t deny that the gesture brought tears to our eyes. The question left by Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9 ‘Another Man’s Shadow,’ is whether Ellen will accept it, especially now that she knows Colum has lost his son. Tragedies have a strange way of bringing families back together.
MORE: INTERVIEW: Blood of My Blood Season 2’s Tony Curran on Lovat’s Lack of Regret
Other Thoughts on Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 Episode 9

- Domestic Brellen is everything that’s right in the world!
- Lovat is already making arrangements for a marriage to Margaret. And, aside from the disgust this causes us, we can’t help but notice that we didn’t see Julia or William at all during the episode. So, our concern is growing—just like Henry’s.
- Murtagh did exactly the right thing by giving that wretch what he deserved.
- Grace… our hearts break for her. How many times did she have to endure that?
- It’s not fair that she and Murtagh have to be separated…
- We don’t know who disgusts us more: John or Hugh Cameron.
Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2 airs on Fridays at 8:00 PM ET only on STARZ and at midnight in STARZ App.