Maxton Hall – The World Between Us is back, and Season 2 Episodes 1-3 wastes no time pulling us back into the world of Ruby Bell and James Beaufort. It’s a messy world — but beautiful — and this season proves just that. The first three episodes of Season 2 dive straight into heartbreak and power, and this season feels different.
The emotions are heavier, and the tone is unlike anything we’ve seen before in this world. It’s darker, deeper, and full of growth. We get to see more of these characters beyond the surface — watching them mature while still feeding us the slow-burn tension that made us fall in love with the series in the first place.
A Heavier, More Emotional Beginning
I absolutely loved these first few episodes. They made me rethink what I thought Maxton Hall was. I can see people’s opinions wavering, since it carries a different feeling with our favorite characters. They aren’t the same as last season, even though not much time has passed — although for Ruby and James, it must feel like it has.
Ruby, played by Harriet Herbig-Matten, and James, played by Damian Hardung, bring the acting this season. Tears — literal tears — fell down my face seeing James in the state he was in during these first few episodes, even when it wasn’t always clear.
Season 2 picks up right where we left off, with no major time jump — and tragedy immediately rocks their world. It hits James’ family hard, and while we’ve seen similar storylines in other series, the way Maxton Hall handles it feels raw. James copes by shutting everyone out, especially Ruby. Their dynamic — what drew me to the series last season — was electric and magnetic, something rare to see captured so well on screen. Going into Season 2, I had a feeling it would be switched, especially based on the trailer. So the connection that was once so powerful is now strained by grief and guilt over James’ mother.
Distance, Grief, and Guilt
The distance between them, especially in Episode 1, was a lot. You could feel it in every scene — not only the physical distance but the emotional one. Even when James was clinging to Ruby, that emotional distance stayed clear. And it hurt. The silence and the eye contact said the most between them.
One of the main moments in Episode 1 was James cheating on Ruby and the aftermath for both characters. At first, I’ll admit it was unclear if Ruby knew about James’ mother’s passing, but I quickly realized we haven’t moved much in time since Season 1.
The acting was incredible — seeing the emotional destruction both individually and together in their relationship was eye-opening. It’s allowing these characters to grow and become their own people before, hopefully, finding their way back to each other by the end of the series.
Ruby’s Strength and James’ Growth
Ruby is still the character we loved in Season 1, but now she’s doing her best to move forward while also trying to support James — all while putting herself first. The emotional drain in their relationship is obvious, even though they love each other so much. She’s focused, grounded, and more guarded this season — which is interesting to see, considering she didn’t even like James at first last season.
Harriet Herbig-Matten brings a quiet emotional strength to Ruby that makes her even more compelling. It shows that Ruby is still the same girl — if not stronger — than before.
We see something similar with James. Damian Hardung adds such complexity to him this season. James is still the boy we swooned over last time, just now struggling to find himself. He’s breaking away from the generational trauma he’s endured. He’s not alone — he has his sister, and when he finds out she’s pregnant, the emotion in that scene is overwhelming. James is no longer just protecting himself; he’s protecting her, too. She’s his family. Watching him deal with his emotions — not just for Ruby, but for himself — is something I can’t wait to see more of.
Love and Power
I love Ruby and James’ relationship. It’s one of the main reasons I started watching the series. Their connection is quiet but full of unspoken words. It’s about more than power and privilege — it’s about what it means for two people from completely different worlds to fall in love, despite all the circumstances working against them.
We see James standing up to his father in these early episodes, becoming more than what people expect him to be. He’s in therapy, and he’s not afraid to step on stage and tell people that he’s doing it. In Episode 3, a flashback shows that Beaufort men were raised to see emotion as disgraceful. Seeing both the present and past versions of James gives us a clearer picture of who he really is. He’s more than the privileged boy or Ruby’s boyfriend — he’s James Beaufort. And sometimes, his last name means nothing at all.
What We Loved
Visually, Maxton Hall has never looked better. While there were a few moments that made me question the series, the cinematography this season is incredible — cinematic even — and the emotions coming through the characters have never been clearer. It’s that boarding-school aesthetic that makes us love the show even more, and somehow, the heartbreak looks stunning.
I know that sounds weird, but visually, the pain is beautiful. Even though Ruby and James’s story is darker, it never loses the romantic pull that hooked us in Season 1. Every scene between them hums with tension — a mix of hurt and love that makes you fall in love with them all over again.
Apart from my beloved Ruby and James, I found the exploration of Ember and Lydia fascinating. Lydia’s story — now being pregnant — carries a lot of emotional weight as she refuses to be defined as “the pregnant Beaufort daughter.” Ember, Ruby’s sister, continues to shine this season as a fashion blogger dealing with her own insecurities. We see more layers to her than before, which makes her storyline even stronger. This season is about more than just Ruby and James — it’s about everyone connected to them.
The chemistry this season is off the charts, and the emotions on screen are unforgettable. Damian’s portrayal of grief and confusion is phenomenal, and Harriet’s performance mirrors that intensity — I felt like I was right there with her, feeling her confusion, heartbreak, and love.
Final Thoughts
I won’t lie, there were moments where the episodes felt a bit dull, even though I was still pulled in by the difference in emotion and atmosphere. I don’t like judging a series until all the episodes are out, but for now, this season brings such a light feeling — even with its darker, more emotional tone. It’s beautifully heartbreaking and captures that sense of change.
Love can’t fix everything — and these first few episodes show that. Even so, it’s worth fighting for. If you came for the love story we all fell for, stay. Because it’s clear it’s coming — even if it’s not in the way we expected.
Agree? Disagree? What did you think of Maxton Hall Season 2, Episodes 1–3? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below!
New episodes of Maxton Hall stream Fridays on Prime Video.
