The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is proof that this franchise’ still got it and that Suzanne Collins can completely change your perspective on a character and make you fall in love with them all over again in one fell swoop. Because I haven’t read the book yet. I purposefully didn’t because I wanted to experience the movie with no preconceived notions besides what I know from the original trilogy and the adaptations that followed. And I ended up loving The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.
On its own, separate from The Hunger Games franchise, Sunrise on the Reaping is a story about how a kind young man was absolutely shattered and changed on a fundamental level because of the trauma he was put through in the games by President Snow. But it’s also an unconventional story of rebellion and hope grounded in someone who loved with all of their heart, chose kindness more often than most people would, and paid dearly for it. Because Katniss might have been the Mockingjay. But the rebellion started long before her with people like Haymitch Abernathy.
MORE: Godzilla Minus Zero Review: How Can Something So Terrifying Also Be Romantic?

Joseph Zada, who plays the young version of Haymitch, did the impossible when it comes to this character. Because I thought I knew him from what we’ve learned from the books or Woody Harrelson’s version in the first adaptations. But through Zada I was able to understand Haymitch’s heartbreak and loss in a way that makes me furious for him but also able to empathize with him and the kind of man that he becomes in the future to numb the pain of what he had lost.
Remember, I haven’t read Sunrise on the Reaping yet. It’s sitting on my shelf as I’m writing this. So this version of Haymitch, I felt like the whole movie was an exercise in mourning what could have been if he never went to the games or the games never existed. And the only thing that was keeping me grounded as we’re experiencing this deadly game, the destruction of this young man, the loss of all his friends and family, was the fact that his name would be the last one ever reaped. Maybe not now. But eventually.
Outside of Zada’s extraordinary performance as Haymitch, major kudos also have to be given to the young women of Sunrise on the Reaping.
MORE: Wildwood Review: The Greatest Stop-Motion Film Ever Made

Mckenna Grace as Maysilee was a force of nature that somehow managed to be determined yet understanding, ferocious yet kind, and someone that felt like family yet was also the enemy. She had multitudes within her and her death was a major loss. Same thing with Lenore. Whitney Peak had me panicking like Annalise from How to Get Away with Murder when everything went down with Bonnie on those steps. If you know, you know. But I was basically yelling, “Stay with me! Stay with me!” as Haymitch held her. She was hope. And I’m never going to look at gummies the same way again.
Then there’s Louella and Lou Lou, respectfully played by Molly McCann and Iona Bell. While watching the movie I didn’t know that they were two different actresses. I just thought that there was something uncanny valley about Lou Lou. But it was two young women. And I knew that as soon as I fell in love with the gentle relationship and bond between Haymitch and Louella, that her death would destroy me. I just didn’t expect her death to be even before we got to the arena; again, proving that The Hunger Games’ still got it when it comes to breaking our hearts.
MORE: Wicker Review: Where’s the Monster Romp I Was Promised?

Outside of the way that it changed how we look at Haymitch and the impeccable acting of everyone, I loved the overall look. Hollywood has gotten a little bit too homogeneous when it comes to their work, with everything looking the same or cheap. You can’t say that about Sunrise on the Reaping. This movie was so distinct when it came to its look, and not just the people from the Capitol. The people from all districts looked like remnants of a lost but familiar era reminiscent of the ’70s. And the wardrobe choices were colorful, cohesive, and felt like the movie actually took the time to make something that wasn’t just a slop sequel.
At the end of the day, if Suzanne Collins wants to tell us a little bit more about beloved characters within The Hunger Games world, I’m sat. Because Sunrise on the Reaping is a testament to how she can create depth that feels distinct but also still within the boundaries of the world she created that criticizes the cruelty of the rich, how desensitized many of us are to the suffering of others, and how governments that are supposed to work for us often treat us like cattle ready for the slaughter.
Additional thoughts about Sunrise on the Reaping:

- What happened to Peeta’s wig?! I loved all the outfits and hair choices of everything we saw on screen for the most part. And this is what you do with Peeta and his wig? We could have done better, people!
- Nevertheless, it was really nice to see Katniss and Peeta. It feels like coming home to your first heartbreak. But the heartbreak is actually ok and living a happy life because the games are over.
- I don’t appreciate the music from “Deep in the Meadow playing because painnnn
- Had a girl crying in the theater!
- Also after what happened with The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, a part of me thinks that Sunrise on the Reaping happened to remind people that Snow is and will always be trash.
- Don’t kill me but Elle Fanning was okay as Effie Trinket. Just okay. I forgot about her in the movie until I saw the red carpet for the New York City premiere and went “Oh yeah, she was in this movie!”
- I did like Glenn Close as Drusilla Sickle. She was cruel and otherworldly. I would give my life for a half an hour cut of Maysilee tearing her down, read for read.
- When it comes to the arenas, I need to sit down and look at a full list of everything that we know so far. Because this arena was astounding. But I think people are going to be thrown off by its beauty, as if that isn’t the whole point of Snow’s maliciousness.
- I heard the squirrel scene with Ampert was worse in the book. I’m not ready.
- I’m also not ready to read what happened to Luella in the books because that chariot scene was literally the most traumatic part of the movie for me
- You know how diabolical Snow is that he changed Haymitch’s teeth. Almost as if to say “You might have gotten out alive. But every single time you look in the mirror, I want you to be reminded of me.” I know it’s a movie change. But still. Diabolical and speaks to Snow’s cruelty.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is now in theaters.