The Way Home Season 4, Episode 1 Review: Show Me The Way To Go Home

I’ve been staring at the screener for the season premiere of The Way Home for weeks, and honestly? I just couldn’t press play. Because the second I did, it meant the beginning of the end—and I wasn’t ready for that. Not even a little. Sure, I know all good things come to an end, but when something is this special and this magical, you can’t help but want more time with it.

Season 4 wastes no time.

The premiere, “Show Me The Way To Go Home,” hits you right in the heart while also completely flipping the rules of the show on their head. The first jaw-dropping moment? The pond can take you forward. That reveal alone changes everything we thought we knew. We open with Del, Kat, and Alice stepping out of the pond into the future—for a wedding. Naturally, my brain went straight to Kat and Elliott… but my heart? It’s quietly rooting for Alice and Max (yes, I said it).

And look, I know Alice and Max aren’t together right now—but I still love them together. There’s something there. They challenge each other, they frustrate each other, and honestly, they both could use a little attitude adjustment. But that’s part of what makes this show so good—it never rushes anything. Like the pond itself, it takes us exactly where we need to go, exactly when we’re supposed to get there.

That’s the brilliance of The Way Home. It feels like it’s opening new doors, introducing new mysteries… but really, the clues have been there all along. It’s all connected, and that’s what makes watching it so rewarding—and so hard to say goodbye to.

ELLIOTT

Back in the “present” (or at least one version of it), Elliott, Kat, and Alice make the decision to jump again—this time to find Elliott’s mom. And I’ll admit, this whole storyline has me on the edge of my seat, but also wanting more for Elliott.

And that alone is surprising.

Elliott has never been my favorite character, but over time, he’s grown on me in a big way. And here, in this episode? My heart actually hurts for him. Imagine knowing your mother chose to jump through time and leave you behind… with no explanation. I’d be pissed. Of course he wants answers—but wanting answers and being ready to face them are two very different things.

And then comes one of the most shocking, emotional moments of the episode: Kat leaving young baby Elliott on the porch for her parents to find… while present-day Elliott and Alice watch it happen. That scene? So very this show.

What I love here is that the story gives Elliott space. He doesn’t have to react the way others expect him to. He’s allowed to feel conflicted, angry, confused—he’s allowed to not want to dig into the past if it hurts too much. And that emotional honesty is something The Way Home consistently gets right.

GRADUATION

We all knew Alice graduating was coming… but I wasn’t prepared for it to feel this soon—or this emotional. I was prepared to be annoyed with Brady, because that is something that definitely happens every time he shows up in Port Haven.

It’s been seven months since that last jump, and now we’re just days away from graduation. Alice has built a life in Port Haven, surrounded by people who love her, and working on a school fundraiser with Max. And yes, even though they’re not together, you can feel that he wants to be.

It’s just hard when the life you built has to change.

For Alice, Max shows up for every time. And despite the complicated history between their families, their friendship feels genuine and earned. I just hope their story doesn’t fall into the same frustrating pattern we’ve seen before with Kat and Elliott. I do hope that Max finds the courage to express himself – long before Alice and him go their separate ways.

More than anything, though, I want Alice to step fully into who she is. She’s one of the most heartfelt characters on television right now—kind, talented, and deeply empathetic. That’s why it hurt so much to see her hesitate to perform her own original song. I can say confidently that viewers are rooting for her. Her music is part of her voice, and I’m rooting for her to embrace it completely before this journey ends.

TIME CAPSULE

I remember there was a point in my life where everything felt like it could be part of a time capsule—like if you buried it deep enough, it would still matter years later, waiting to be uncovered at just the right time. And that’s exactly what this episode taps into in The Way Home.

So I was genuinely surprised to learn that Colton and Del actually made one. Yes, I know that the clues had always been there. The time capsule hunt suddenly makes all those holes Del was digging in the front yard make way more sense—she wasn’t being random, she was searching for it. Del was searching for the past and for answers. For something she helped bury without fully understanding what it would become.

Inside that time capsule is a letter Del wrote, meant for her firstborn someday. Except when she finally holds it again, she doesn’t even remember what she wrote. She reads it aloud to Alice… but it quickly becomes clear that this isn’t really Alice’s letter. It’s Kat’s. It only makes sense when it’s read to Kat.

And only after it’s read does Del’s memory seem to click back into place—like the emotion of it finally unlocks the truth behind it.

Meanwhile, Jake is gone—off to Toronto, out of reach, not staying in contact. And honestly? That immediately sets off alarm bells. Especially after he sent Alice those Alice in Wonderland books. That’s not subtle. That’s intentional. And I don’t trust it. Something about him feels like he knows more than he’s saying, and in a show like The Way Home, that kind of silence is never random.

But Jake leaving also shifts everything for Del. It makes her hold on tighter to Kat, like she’s afraid that if she loosens her grip even a little, she’ll lose her too. And in response, she pushes Alice toward something surprisingly tender—creating her own time capsule. She tells Alice to remember where it’s buried. Preserving pieces of herself for the future.

Even more emotional is what Del suggests next: writing a letter to a future child. And I’ll be honest, I’ve long had this feeling that we may have already met Alice’s daughter somewhere in this timeline. This show doesn’t place details like that by accident.

When Alice goes to bury her time capsule, she stumbles onto something she absolutely wasn’t expecting—Elliott’s mom’s suitcase. And that moment changes everything. It’s the first time Elliott sees a real, tangible connection to her—a photo of the two of them together. Him and his mother, frozen in a moment that time hasn’t erased.

It also becomes the moment everything clicks about Fern’s riddles. Those chants weren’t just strange words—they were clues. Clues pointing toward Elliott’s mom, and everything tied to her disappearance. Her jump.

Elliott spends so long insisting he doesn’t want to go back, doesn’t want to jump, doesn’t want answers… but in the end, he finally says it out loud: he does want to jump.

And honestly? I’m relieved.

Because watching Elliott struggle with grief, hesitation, hi emotional wall—it’s been heavy. And when he couldn’t jump before, you could see exactly how much it hurt him to be held back by fear. Elliott deserves clarity, a much as he deserves truth. He deserves better than being stuck on the outside of his own story.

And in The Way Home, that kind of choice never comes without consequence.

SILENT ’25

When it comes to Alice and Max, their argument in this episode ends up setting something much bigger in motion—because of course it does. This is The Way Home, where even the smallest emotional moments can crack open entire timelines.

And lets face it – these two are definitely a piece of many cracked open timelines.

Still upset and waiting for Max to bring her the pictures he has of hers, Alice drifts into the living room. It’s there that she finds Lewis watching an old film. And not just any film—this one takes us back to a time when Port Haven was trying its hand at Hollywood, complete with a silent movie and big dreams. Fern had auditioned… and as Alice watches that footage, everything shifts.

Because there – in a silent film from 1925 – in walks Kat.

Casually stepping into frame like it’s no big deal… except it is a very big deal. This is confirmation: Kat makes it back to 1925. But the question immediately becomes why? And maybe more importantly… what happens there?

The tone of that footage isn’t light or nostalgic—it’s unsettling. Kat and Fern both look genuinely terrified, like they’ve seen something they can’t unsee. And if there’s one thing this show does brilliantly, it’s using tiny glimpses like this to foreshadow something much bigger.

Fern, who has always spoken in riddles, suddenly feels even more important. Those cryptic clues she’s been dropping? They’re not random—they’re pieces of a puzzle that’s finally starting to come together.

Back in the present, when Kat and Elliott try to jump together, the pond refuses him. It’s such a specific, intentional choice—and now, thanks to that film, Alice knows something is very, very wrong. She’s seen the fear on her mom’s face. She knows there’s more to the story.

So she does what Alice does best—she follows her instincts. She jumps.

But of course, the pond doesn’t make it easy. It never does.

Instead of landing together, they’re sent to different times. And waiting there? Fern. Watching. Knowing. Asking them what time period they’ve come from like this is all part of something she already understands.

And that’s the question that won’t leave my mind after this episode:

What does Fern actually know?

Because at this point, it feels like she knows everything.

If this premiere is any indication, The Way Home is setting us up for an unforgettable final chapter—one that’s emotional, surprising, and full of the kind of storytelling that made us fall in love with it in the first place. And even though I’m not ready to say goodbye… I already know it’s going to be beautiful, painful, and a trip that only the pond could take up on.

OTHER THOUGHT

• I think Sam is Coltons brother
• Wait – the wall with the clock is from the 20s? I forgot about that.
• I really want Max and Alice together
• If we end with Kat and Elliott’s wedding, I am gonna be mad
• Alice getting her own car – love it. Also haven’t seen one of those in ages.
• Brady bragging about money – gross
• Jacob – I am mad you left
• I don’t trust Sam
• Elliott needs to pop the question rather than just being like I am gonna do it at the end of the summer
• Brady telling Elliott to pop the question — it’s bad if Brady is telling you to do something